The Law of Work
  • Home
  • About
  • Professor David Doorey
  • Osgoode Hall LLM
  • Books
  • Guest Contributors
  • Useful Links
    • Archive
  • Home
  • About
  • Professor David Doorey
  • Osgoode Hall LLM
  • Books
  • Guest Contributors
  • Useful Links
    • Archive
The Law of Work
Law of Work Archive

When is a Resignation a Wrongful Dismissal?

by David Doorey November 23, 2011
written by David Doorey November 23, 2011

If you are an HR manager and one of your employees provides you with a letter of resignation, you do not have to provide that employee with reasonable notice or statutory notice. Right?
The answer is that it depends. It depends on whether the employee actually resigned voluntarily and intended to do so. If an employee believes she is about to be dismissed, and decides it is better to quit than be fired, then there is a good chance the employer still has to provide notice of termination. If the employee is being driven out by the employer, then a quit is not voluntary and will be treated by the court as a dismissal without cause entitling the employee to proper notice of termination.
There are lots of cases on this point. The latest is from B.C., called Chan v. Dencan Restaurants, issued earlier this month.   Chan worked for a franchisor of Denny’s restaurants.  Twice he was told by his superior that he should consider quitting because otherwise he would be dismissed.  He actually resigned twice, but then was hired back.  Then, in October 2010, the manager once again told the employee that he should quit, or he would be fired.  The employee decided to resign, and sent a letter saying:

After my vacation ended a week ago, I then realized that my wife needs my attention more than I anticipated as well as looking after my own health–advised by my family physician to slow down.

In fact, none of that was true, but the employee felt he was about to be dismissed and wanted to “save face”.
The Court noted that a resignation letter is not a resignation.  It is only evidence of intention to terminate the employment contract.  The real question is “who terminated the employment relationship?”  The Court observed:

When an employee is left with no choice but to resign or be fired, the resignation is not voluntary and a letter of resignation is tantamount to a dismissal: Deters v Prince Albert Fraser House Inc. (1991), 93 Sask. R. 205, 4 W.A.C. 205 at para. 13.

This is what happened in this case, the Court ruled.  Therefore, Chan was entitled to damages for “reasonable notice”.  Since he was a long service, managerial employee, aged 63, the Court set that notice towards the outer limit of notice, at 18 months.  The Court noted that the repeated threats to dismiss the employee if he did not quit “come very close to meeting the test of unfair or bad faith conduct” in the manner of dismissal (Honda damages).  Very close?  I’d say that behaviour is well within the range of the bad faith dismissal.  However, the Court refuses to order those damages because the employee had not present expert medical evidence that this misconduct caused him additional physical harm.   The employees’ doctor was called as an witness to testify that the employee had been prescribed anti-depressants.  However, the doctor had not been tendered as an “expert” and therefore could not testify as to the cause of the depression.
What should an employer do when it received a resignation letter from an employee under circumstances in which there is reason to doubt that the employee truly wishes to quit?

0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterLinkedinEmail
David Doorey

Professor Doorey is an Associate Professor of Work Law and Industrial Relations at York University. He is Academic Director of Osgoode Hall Law School’s executive LLM Program in Labour and Employment Law and a Senior Research Associate at Harvard Law School’s Labor and Worklife Program. Professor Doorey is a graduate of Osgoode Hall Law School (LL.B., Ph.D), London School of Economics (LLM Labour Law), and the University of Toronto (B.A., M.I.R.).

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

previous post
The Bad Employer Sunshine List for September 2011
next post
Should HRM Support or Fight Against Move towards Precarious Work?

You may also like

This Blog Entry is About the Lunacy of...

July 21, 2019

A Cross Country Update on the Card-Check versus...

October 3, 2018

The Folly of Not Voting to Strike in...

September 16, 2018

Unifor Posts Photos of Replacement Workers as Gander...

September 10, 2018

A Wrongful Dismissal Case and the Absence of...

August 29, 2018

China Said to Quickly Withdraw Approval for New...

August 27, 2018

The Latest Hot E-Commerce Idea in China: The...

August 27, 2018

The Trump Administration Just Did Something Unambiguously Good...

August 27, 2018

Unstable Situations Require Police In Riot Gear Face...

August 27, 2018

Trump’s War on the Justice System Threatens to...

August 27, 2018

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 338 other subscribers

Follow Us On Social Media

Twitter

Latest Tweets

David J. Doorey🇨🇦Follow

Law Prof. Talking #labor & #employment #law #Gig to the masses. Alpaca ❤️ @YorkUniversity @OsgoodeNews @LSELaw @LWPHarvard @Jacobin @OnLaborBlog https://t.co/5V9r8VPHsh

David J. Doorey🇨🇦
Retweet on TwitterDavid J. Doorey🇨🇦 Retweeted
AnthonyForsyt10Anthony Forsyth@AnthonyForsyt10·
3h

If you missed my ⁦@RMIT⁩ lecture on Tuesday here is the text with a recording to follow … Legislating to Rebuild Worker Power: The Industrial Relations Reforms We Need from the Albanese Labor Government - Labour Law Down Under ⁦⁦@RMITCoBL⁩ https://labourlawdownunder.com.au/?p=1042

Reply on Twitter 1560086376703750144Retweet on Twitter 15600863767037501444Like on Twitter 156008637670375014412Twitter 1560086376703750144
TheLawofWorkDavid J. Doorey🇨🇦@TheLawofWork·
7h

Old law school friend now works as a lawyer in the Office of the JAG. She is doing basic training, getting crazy fit. I wasn’t aware these lawyers must basically go thru basic training.

Imagine if there was a fitness test for labour and employment lawyers?

Reply on Twitter 1560028418015522817Retweet on Twitter 1560028418015522817Like on Twitter 15600284180155228178Twitter 1560028418015522817
TheLawofWorkDavid J. Doorey🇨🇦@TheLawofWork·
7h

You’ve seen this article?

Adrienne Cuoto, ‘Clothing Exotic Dancers with Collective Bargaining Rights’, 2006 38-1 Ottawa Law Review 37, 2006 CanLIIDocs 63, <https://canlii.ca/t/2913>

ryan white@ryandwhite12

One of my COVID projects has been working on a history of the Canadian Association of Burlesque Entertainers, the only case I am aware of in which dancers sought unionization in Canada - so I will be watching this carefully (it is rare and exciting) https://twitter.com/grimkim/status/1559995539999031297

Reply on Twitter 1560023264759615499Retweet on Twitter 15600232647596154991Like on Twitter 1560023264759615499Twitter 1560023264759615499
Load More...

Categories

  • Alberta
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Australia
  • British Columbia
  • Charter of Rights and Freedoms
  • Childcare
  • Class Action
  • Climate and Just Transition
  • Collective Bargaining
  • Common Law of Employment
  • Comparative Work Law
  • competition law
  • construction
  • COVID-19
  • Diversity
  • Employee Classification
  • Employment Insurance
  • Employment Regulation
  • Europe
  • Financial Industry
  • Fissured Work
  • Freedom of Association
  • frustration of contract
  • Gig Work
  • Health and Safety
  • Health Care
  • Human Rights
  • Immigration
  • Interest Arbitration
  • International Law
  • Labour Arbitration
  • Labour Economics
  • Law of Work Archive
  • Legal Profession
  • Manitoba
  • Migrant Workers
  • Minimum Wage
  • Nova Scotia
  • OLRB
  • Ontario
  • Pension Bankruptcy
  • Privacy
  • Public Sector
  • Quebec
  • Real Life Pleadings
  • Saskatchewan
  • Scholarship
  • Sports Labour
  • Strikes and Lockouts
  • Student Post
  • Supreme Court of Canada
  • technology
  • Transnational Law
  • Uncategorized
  • Unions and Collective Bargaining
  • United States
  • Videos
  • Women and Work
  • Wrongful Dismissal
  • Home
  • About
  • Guest Contributors
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Guest Contributors
  • Legal Scholarship
  • Useful Links
  • Archive
Menu
  • Legal Scholarship
  • Useful Links
  • Archive

2020. Canadian Law of Work Forum. All Rights Reserved.